Mobile Menu

  • Home
    • About Lindsay
  • Blog
    • English Language Arts
    • Effective Teaching Strategies
    • Technology in the Classroom
    • Self Care for Teachers
  • Free Grading Guide
  • Grading Reset Course
  • Resources
    • Web Store
    • TpT Store
  • Menu
  • Skip to right header navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Before Header

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Lindsay Ann Learning English Teacher Blog

Erasing the English Teacher Status Quo

  • Home
    • About Lindsay
  • Blog
    • English Language Arts
    • Effective Teaching Strategies
    • Technology in the Classroom
    • Self Care for Teachers
  • Free Grading Guide
  • Grading Reset Course
  • Resources
    • Web Store
    • TpT Store

Upgrade Harkness Discussion with Equity Maps

Home » Blog » Technology in the Classroom » Upgrade Harkness Discussion with Equity Maps

March 23, 2020 //  by Lindsay Ann//  5 Comments

Sharing is caring!

  • Share
  • Tweet

Because I value student-led learning, I am always trying to find ways to involve students in discussions. I love using the fishbowl method, Socratic seminars, Harkness Discussions, and literature circles to spark student conversation. To make these assignments student-led, I ask students to use conversation stems, backchannel chat, and methods such as the TQE method to help students generate awesome questions.

Why Harkness Discussion?

Earlier this year, the Harkness discussion strategy came onto my radar when a colleague shared a discussion placemat with me for use during a Born a Crime assignment. We had been focusing on question generation using the TQE method, and it seemed like the Harkness Model fit in with our goals for student-led discourse. 

The Harkness Method isn’t earth-shattering or even innovative, but it does put the responsibility onto the students for facilitating their own conversation.

You might be wondering how Harkness Discussion differs from a Fishbowl discussion or Socratic Seminar or literature circle. If you, like me, usually take a facilitator role during these types of conversations, then the difference is subtle.

Harkness Discussion vs. Other Student Led Discussion Methods

Developed at the Phillips Exeter Academy, the Harkness Method asks the teacher to guide student talk with the goal of helping learners ask really good questions and making sure every voice is heard.

Unlike the Socratic seminar, the student-led conversation is shaped by several questions rather than one essential question. Beyond this, what distinguishes it from other teaching strategies, to me, is the role of the student observer. 

During the conversation, one student sits back to observe group dynamics, patterns of conversation, flow and balance of discussion, as well as other items of interest. The goal of the student observer is to serve as a neutral third-party witness to the conversation in order to provide the group with “data” about their speaking and listening skills.

In the end, what sets this strategy apart from these other methods is that it emphasizes the co-creation of knowledge through questioning AND encourages higher-level metacognitive skills. Students are asked to be aware of themselves as a part of a larger conversation and reflect. 

As I said, the difference is subtle, yet effective. And, if you are wondering, YES, you can integrate the Harkness discussion method with literature circles, fishbowls, or Socratic seminars.

Using Technology for Discussion

When using Equity Maps for Harkness discussion, the role of the student observer is empowered by data. 

This iPad app is easy to set up and does not interfere with discussion in any way. In fact, it records the flow of conversation (and can even play it back in real or fast-forwarded time), keeps track of who participates and for how long, and draws lines between speakers to map the conversation.

The goal of Equity Maps is to create balanced conversation in which every voice is heard and valued. Once students discuss, the group can look at and interpret the data, set group goals, and work to improve their speaking and listening skills.

If your students are like mine, they will be very interested in looking at their analytics. What’s more, reflective conversations are a natural byproduct of looking at this data. As a teacher, you will just need to harness the power of that reflection potential by giving students time to think and make sense of their data and draw conclusions.

harkness-discussion

If you aren’t keeping a student out of the conversation as a neutral observer, in true Harkness form, this app can play the role of a neutral observer. Set it in the middle of the table and students “tap in” when they begin speaking.

This leads me to mention that it is really important to set-up the conversation so that all students can see each other. 

Over time, if you choose to keep students in the same groups, this tool can allow for comparison of data between discussions. Are students really meeting their goals and improving over time? Have groups take a look at the numbers, graphs, and flow of their discussion to prove it

Equity Maps Has a Nominal Cost

The standard version of Equity Maps is $1.99 and allows you to map up to 20 participants at one time. I understand that resources are sometimes limited. But, if you’re able to use school-issued iPads with the app installed, it is ideal to have one device per group (if you have multiple groups running at the same time). 

Next year, I intend to apply for grant money to facilitate use of Equity Maps as we’ve run into problems with our district funding the app and doing away with iPad technology in favor of Chromebooks.

How Equity Maps Works

Below, I’ve created some images to walk you through the set-up process and to show you some of the analytics.

Prior to the conversation, students will initially need 5-10 minutes to set-up the app. 

First, when you enter the Equity Maps app, you will be shown different table arrangements. I have students choose the square or rectangle one.

harkness-discussion

Next, students will set up group members, adding each individual and his/her information to an avatar card (and choosing a color).

harkness-discussion

Once group members are created, simply drag each avatar to the appropriate spot around the table.

harkness-discussion

To begin mapping, simply tap the avatar of the student as he or she begins to speak. When he or she is finished, tap on the next student who talks. Continue this until the conversation is finished.

harkness-discussion

To zoom in on the mapping screen, there are different options to explore. This app is not only useful for Harkness discussion, but also think-pair-share, spider mapping, literature circles, fishbowl discussions, Socratic seminars, and pinwheel discussions, to name a few.

harkness-discussion

After the dialogue is complete, students can look at their data in different ways. I love how students are able to “playback” their conversation.

In addition, the lines show the conversation flow. It’s interesting to consider not only the flow of lines to and from a student, but also to notice patterns in the lines.

For example, does conversation ping-pong back and forth between the same students? If so, the line becomes darker. Who has the most lines? The least? Is there an order to who speaks?

You can also playback the conversation and actually have students listen to what they said.

harkness-discussion

Beyond this playback and mapping screen, students can dig into group analytics.

harkness-discussion

Because the goal of student talk is equity between participants, students can use the data to reflect on air time and gender group dynamics. They can also zoom in to view individual student statistics. 

Here’s an example of an overall statistics page:

harkness-discussion

From here, students can zoom in and consider data in the following ways:

harkness-discussion
harkness-discussion
harkness-discussion

Lastly, as I said before, you can track student progress over time and celebrate growth. As students make sense of the data through reflection and set personal and group goals for future discussions, you can help them learn these important speaking and listening skills for success in LIFE!

harkness-discussion

Hey, if you loved this post, I want to be sure you’ve had the chance to grab a FREE copy of my guide to streamlined grading. I know how hard it is to do all the things as an English teacher, so I’m over the moon to be able to share with you some of my best strategies for reducing the grading overwhelm.

Click on the link above or the image below to get started!

grading-papers

Sharing is caring!

  • Share
  • Tweet

Category: Effective Teaching Strategies, English Language Arts, Technology in the ClassroomTag: Classroom Discussion, discussion strategies, student engagement, teaching strategies

About Lindsay Ann

Lindsay has been teaching high school English in the burbs of Chicago for 18 years. She is passionate about helping English teachers find balance in their lives and teaching practice through practical feedback strategies and student-led learning strategies. She also geeks out about literary analysis, inquiry-based learning, and classroom technology integration. When Lindsay is not teaching, she enjoys playing with her two kids, running, and getting lost in a good book.

Related Posts

You may be interested in these posts from the same category.

figurative-language-examples

Figurative Language Examples We Can All Learn From

growth-mindset-versus-fixed-mindset

18 Ways to Encourage Growth Mindset Versus Fixed Mindset in High School Classrooms

song-analysis

10 Song Analysis Lessons for Teachers

blended-learning

10 Tips for Making the Most of Blended Learning

classroom-technology

10 Tips for Effective Classroom Technology Integration in the English Language Arts Classroom

conversation-starters

Must-Have Table Topics Conversation Starters

mtss-framework

Warning: These 9 Mistakes Will Destroy Your MTSS

writing-process

The Writing Process Explained: From Outline to Final Draft

authentic-assessments

What Are Authentic Assessments?

writing-narratives

The Art of Storytelling: Techniques for Writing Engaging Narratives

writing-topics

Writing Topics for Student Writer’s Block

The Art of Argumentation: How to Write a Convincing Argumentative Essay

Previous Post: «independent-reading Revive High School Independent Reading
Next Post: The Secret of Introduction Writing introduction-writing»

Reader Interactions

Trackbacks

  1. Start Building Rapport with Students Using Check-Ins | English Teacher Blog says:
    July 20, 2020 at 11:01 am

    […] choice boards, student discussion trackers, or authentic assessments to engage […]

    Reply
  2. Backwards Planning Like a Boss | Lindsay Ann Learning says:
    November 9, 2020 at 12:06 pm

    […] My team decided to focus on building student talk with Harkness and TQE discussions during quarter one. From there, students would, during the second quarter, be […]

    Reply
  3. How to Teach Growth Mindset vs. Fixed Mindset in High School | English Teacher Blog says:
    December 11, 2020 at 9:07 am

    […] Student Led DiscussionDiscussion, an active, rich sharing of ideas should happen regularly and not always for an assessment grade. I believe that the more students […]

    Reply
  4. 10 Reasons to Try Round Table Discussions - Lindsay Ann Learning English Teacher Blog says:
    May 6, 2023 at 11:46 am

    […] whole class discussion strategies and small group discussion strategies like: Socratic Seminar, Harkness discussions, Pinwheel discussions, Fishbowls, Snowball discussions, or Hot Seat, roundtable discussions may […]

    Reply
  5. Student Led Discussion Strategies for Whole Class Discussion says:
    May 6, 2023 at 10:11 pm

    […] Upgrade Harkness Discussions with Equity Maps […]

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Primary Sidebar

Join me in the pursuit of engaged, dynamic classroom learning!

I’ve created a FREE guide with 20 of my best strategies for streamlined grading to help English teachers like you have more time to do what you love.

Get the Guide!

Categories

Latest Products

  • Late Work Submission Google Form $3.00
  • Rhetorical Devices Activities for Google Drive & Print $4.00
  • Distance Learning Google Form Student Survey $3.00
  • Creative Writing Prompts Choice Boards $3.00
  • Slam Poetry Condensed Unit for Distance Learning $7.00

Site Footer

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Copyright © 2023 Lindsay Ann Learning English Teacher Blog · Privacy · All Rights Reserved

79 shares